Today I went looking for this cache: Thank You David Dear (Cache 1)

and found this one too: It's Dear In Dundee, Or... (Cache 2)

I removed the box with it's contents thinking it was a Missing box for Cache 1.
My plan was to contact the cache owner and return the items, which were an unsigned log (with the GC code at the top) and a wooden coin.
Cache 2 was last found about a year ago and was archived in September. Cache 1 was placed as a replacement for the other by a diferent cacher.

Now do I log Cache 2 as a find even though it is archived?
(I did find it within about a foot of where it was supposed to be )

What do you think I should do with the cache and contents as the owner was contacted prior to it being archived, there was no reply and their profile shows them as not being active since 2007.
On further investigation I have noticed quite alot of their caches have gone =0(